Skip to main content

Multiple Offers as Leverage

Real or apparent competition among buyers is the single biggest driver of the price and terms you can command.

Why Competition Drives Price​

Across all three sources, the core mechanic of a strong sale is the same: a seller has leverage only when more than one buyer wants the business. Warrillow frames competition as the engine of "Punching Above Your Weight," the section of his book devoted to manufacturing competitive tension so that buyers, not the seller, feel the pressure to move. Burlingham puts it bluntly through M&A veteran Basil Peters, for whom going to market with a single buyer is one of the cardinal mistakes of selling a company.

"Every exit needs multiple bidders."

Burlingham, Finish Big, ch. 6

A lone buyer knows it is the only game in town. It can drag out diligence, re-trade the price, and harden terms with little risk of losing the deal. Two or more buyers reverse that pressure entirely.

The Proprietary Deal Trap​

The opposite of a competitive process is what Warrillow calls the proprietary or "prop" deal: an exclusive negotiation with one buyer who has courted the owner privately. He warns that these flattering, friendly overtures are designed precisely to keep the seller out of a competitive process.

"They will try to make you believe they are your friend. Don't believe them."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 4

Without a rival bid, the seller has surrendered the one lever that moves price. The buyer can low-ball, knowing there is no alternative offer to walk to.

Manufacturing the Competition​

You do not always need a literal bidding war. Warrillow argues that even the appearance of competition shifts the dynamic. A buyer-ready information package, prepared before going to market, signals that other buyers are or could be in the room.

"A professionally prepared pre-diligence package is a subtle but powerful way to create competitive tension for your business—even if none exists."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 3

McDannell offers a concrete mechanic for the self-serve seller: set an offer date so that interested buyers must submit their LOIs by the same deadline. Clustering offers creates genuine fear of missing out and lets the seller compare bids side by side rather than negotiating one at a time. Her one rule about it is absolute: never lie about competing offers. A single caught lie collapses buyer trust and the whole process with it.

Reading the Offers You Get​

More offers do not mean simply taking the biggest number. McDannell stresses that competing bids rarely line up cleanly, because each carries different structure, financing, cash at close, and likelihood of actually closing.

"Having multiple offers on the table is not like comparing apples to apples. It's more like comparing apples to carrots to candy bars."

McDannell, Get Acquired, ch. 6

The leverage from competition is therefore twofold: it raises the headline price, and it gives the seller real alternatives to weigh on terms and certainty, not just on the number at the top of the page. Keeping a second bidder alive is also the strongest defense against a buyer who tries to re-trade after the LOI is signed.

Further Reading​

Sources: Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business ch.3-4, ch.13; McDannell, Get Acquired ch.6; Burlingham, Finish Big ch.6.